Unless the case was a federal case US vs named individuals, the records should be in the county courthouses or their archives.
Carter County Courthouse
300 W Main Street
Grayson, KY 41143
Boyd County Courthouse
2800 Louisa Street
Catlettsburg, KY 41229
Thank you! I wasn't able to find what I need online but will try contacting them directly.
Welcome to History Hub
The following article was found on RootsWeb.com
Did Christ Die for Sinners Weep
The Story of the First legal Hanging in Carter County
© Glen R Haney 2007
Thank you, Alice!