Thank you for using the History Hub. The web address you are showing is for his Prison Record. You will need to check with the Superior Court of Michigan for his Criminal Record. This is usually digitized and accessible from their Web Site. It could be free or it may cost you a buck or two to download it.
Welcome to History Hub,
I found the following about William Stafford and Andrew Reecer
Find a Grave for William Stafford has copy of newspaper article about the stabbing.
1910 census Tennessee
United States World War I Draft Registration Cards, 1917-1918
Found Andrew Reecer in the 1940 census as a Lodger
Andrew Reecer Death Certificate from Ancestry.com. it is a pay site but they give a free trial.
Good Luck in your search
Dear Mr. Smith,
Thank you for posting your request on History Hub!
The National Archives and Records Administration does not have custody of records created by state or local governments. The link you provided is to the Indiana Archives and Records Administration. Please contact them for questions about state records. According to the temporary closing announcement on their main page, the Indiana State Archives is currently closed to the public, and many of their staff are working from home. However, they are still available to help with your reference questions. The best way to reach them is via email at firstname.lastname@example.org.
We hope this information is helpful. Best of luck with your research!