Hi J Purkaple,
Welcome to the Hub.
I found a Katherine Pierce on Ancestry.com, she has a family tree with Peter Marchal in it and also has 1829 Clermont, Puy-de-Dôme, Auvergne, France as his birth place
Pierre Marechal was born on March 9, 1829, in Puy-de-Dôme, France, to Louise Montagu, age 29, and Claude Marechal, age 24.
9 Mar 1829 • Clarmont-Ferrand, Puy-de-Dôme, Auvergne, France
Ancestry is a pay site.
Thank you so much. I have been told, however, that Peter Marshall, even in the original French spelling variations, is the equivalent of John Smith over there -- that there's loads of them in France. How can I know if this is my guy? This is 1829, which is close to 1827-1828, from records I have, but it's technically outside the range. Is there a marriage record for this guy, or record of his emigration out of France?
Sadly, apparently, Marion County (Illinois) did not keep or maintain any old naturalization petitions, and you're very lucky to find any naturalization papers there from the 1800s of any kind. Church records have not turned up anything either. Can't find them anywhere. Obituaries and death and marriage records and census records never say anything specific beyond just France. Their daughter Mary M. was a great-great-grandmother of mine, I descend from her only daughter. Mary's daughter was born of her first marriage, but I have seen a record of Mary's second marriage, to my Great-Grandma's stepfather. That record gives Mary's parents' names as Mary (Eartiedies) and Peter Marshall. I have never found anything about the surname Eartiedies after years of searching, and am forced to conclude that it was probably just an awful misspelling. Mary's brother George Marshall Sr. was married in Illinois also, and his marriage record lists his parents as Mary (Ordel) and Peter Marshall. Descendants of George Sr. have said in the past that his mother's maiden surname was Ordel or Ordell or Ordelle because of that marriage record. I have been unable to find any records about people with that surname from France either. Again I feel I must conclude that the name was terribly misspelled. But we know it's the same woman. Peter is sometimes incorrectly listed as George Peter, or George Peter Sr. because of his son George's death cert. There is nothing else to back this up and I can't bring myself to support that as having been Peter's actual full given name.