I am trying to find out more about Franklin Charles Cave who died at Gettysburg on 23 July 1863 after being wounded on 1 July 1863. My question is, are there any records that might help identify which field hospital(s) he was in

My great great grandfather, William Henry Cave, and his younger brother, Franklin Charles Cave, were both in Company I of the Ninth New York Volunteer Cavalry at Gettysburg. They had volunteered in November of 1862 for nine months. I believe they were recruited as replacements for casualties to the regiment which had been originally mustered into service in October 1861. According to their compiled service records both of them were assigned to detached duties until just before the battle at Gettysburg. I don't have any confirmation that William fought in the battle, though he was reported on the muster rolls for July as present, but I know his brother Franklin was mortally wounded there during the afternoon of 1 July 1863. His service record has documents stating that he was, "wounded in his right breast," and that he "died on 23 July 1863 at Gettysburg." I've read a couple of books about the aftermath at Gettysburg as well as the "HIstory of the Ninth New York Volunteer Cavalry" by Newel Cheney, which gives a brief account of the action where Franklin was wounded, but the number of possible aid stations and the confusion that reigned during the remaining days of the battle has made it impossible to determine much about what happened to him after he was wounded. I was wondering if there are any records available about who was cared for in the various field hospitals and what treatment they may have received.  

Parents
  • Timstimes.... I have stumbled across your question while I was researching your Great-Great Grand Uncle (Franklin Charles Cave)...just off the cuff your ancestors regiment the 9th NY Cav was part of Buford's 1st Cavalry Division. At least initially the whole division established its hospital in the Presbyterian Church in the downtown. Start there. Eventually sometime after the 21st of July Camp Letterman became operational. With Letterman open all other division and corps hospitals slowly closed up in an effort to consolidate.

    What I am really interested in is where your G-G-Uncle is buried. Not sure I have the ability to email directly, but it is an enigma. He should have been identifiable. He is not in Gettysburg. There is a stone for him in the Mina Cemetery in Chautaugua, NY. What I have been researching and writing to folks about for the better part of this year is...if anyone knows if he is actually "physically" buried there? Or if the stone present is simply a memorial or cenotaph? 

    I have checked every available online resource (ancestry, newspapers, find-a-grave, straight google, handwritten letters to former groundskeepers for the cemetery, and historical societies. Nothing. I will settle for legend and lore if anyone in your family has a second hand account of Franklin's return home, if in fact he did. 

    Thank you!

Reply
  • Timstimes.... I have stumbled across your question while I was researching your Great-Great Grand Uncle (Franklin Charles Cave)...just off the cuff your ancestors regiment the 9th NY Cav was part of Buford's 1st Cavalry Division. At least initially the whole division established its hospital in the Presbyterian Church in the downtown. Start there. Eventually sometime after the 21st of July Camp Letterman became operational. With Letterman open all other division and corps hospitals slowly closed up in an effort to consolidate.

    What I am really interested in is where your G-G-Uncle is buried. Not sure I have the ability to email directly, but it is an enigma. He should have been identifiable. He is not in Gettysburg. There is a stone for him in the Mina Cemetery in Chautaugua, NY. What I have been researching and writing to folks about for the better part of this year is...if anyone knows if he is actually "physically" buried there? Or if the stone present is simply a memorial or cenotaph? 

    I have checked every available online resource (ancestry, newspapers, find-a-grave, straight google, handwritten letters to former groundskeepers for the cemetery, and historical societies. Nothing. I will settle for legend and lore if anyone in your family has a second hand account of Franklin's return home, if in fact he did. 

    Thank you!

Children
  • Hello Irishx5, thanks for the information about the Presbyterian Church. I'm not sure about Camp Letterman since he died two days after it opened.

    As for his burial, I have visited the cemetery in Mina, but I have no evidence one way or another as to whether or not he is actually buried there. I was born and have lived in California almost my entire life though most of my dad's family stayed in Chautauqua County. So, I have had limited contact with them over the years. My interest in family history started fairly late in life so I missed a number of opportunities to talk to the older members of the family and ask them these questions. My own family connection to the Cave family is through my great grandmother, Jennie Cave--daughter of William Cave. I have had no contact with any of the Cave family myself and Jennie died in 1917, before my dad was born. The only person I can think of who might know anything about it is my dad's twin brother's widow. I don't think it's likely she would know anything as neither my dad or his brother had any interest in family history, but I can send her an e-mail and ask.

    I did read somewhere that there were people who, for a price, would prepare and ship bodies back to their hometown during the war, though it seems unlikely any records exist from that trade.

    Tim